When Kew Gardens was first subdivided, no land was set aside for a school. The first P.S. 99 was a portable wooden school house on Cuthbert Road. In 1915, Alrick Man proposed a site on the east side of Kew Gardens Road at Augustine (83rd) Avenue. Between 1920 and 1923, the Board of Education suggested a number of alternative sites - the Forest Hills side of Union Turnpike, the east side of Lefferts Boulevard, Forest Park on Park Lane, and Quentin Street (80th Road) near Park Lane - all of which were opposed by the Community. In January, 1923, the City's Board of Estimate finally approved the very site Man had suggested 8 years earlier. P.S. 99 opened in 1924.